2004 Report

2005 Update:
LHH defensive liability who has moved backwards for me. Body still in top shape. Broad wide
shoulders and developed back. High hips. Very long legs. Nothing he does is esp. athletic. Some
cave man in him. Swing path has gotten worse and batspd not what it was last yr. so swings
issues are much more visible. Big loop with hds and bathead out in front of head makes it very
hard to get bat in right position against quality stuff. Way too long. Late in season tried to
eliminate loop and simply load his hds straight down but after a couple weeks he was back to
old loop and now with an ugly hand hitch. Don't like plate disc. Tweener-high K's but he's not
letting swing really go when he does swing, once he commits it's more of a contact approach.
Soft .300 for me with huge K's and few BB's. Lots of soft GB's to right side. Can't get around
on quality stuff under his hds with hd loop and I'm not confident he'll be able to rid himself of
it. Pitchers @ upper levels will exploit it. Front shoulder leaks. Still shows off plus raw power.
Power not going to be enuf to wash out lack of avg and subpar defensive skills. Fringy runner
who should end up adeq. on bases. Strong avg throwing arm suitable for RF. Short INF release.
Can get a lot on it off of his back ft-lots of chances to do it. Makes mistakes every night with
leather-don't see any improvement. Never gets camped under a ball, constantly on move and
catching balls in full stride after bad breaks. As mentioned with throwing, doesn't get behind
ball to set up to throw. Arm could easily be plus if he had proper footwork. Should get some
big league time but for me he is an up and down type player who could be eaten alive with gd
advance scouting-thus the interest in short spurts @ big league level. Swing much too
complicated and he's streaky to like him as a lefty bat off bench.


Nate Schierholtz
San Jose Giants
San Francisco Giants
OF/DH
L/R
6'2''/215
2/15/84
2nd RD 2003 Draft
Low A/High A
Native of Danville, CA attended Chabot
(CA) JC.
30
8/26/05
30
40
35
45
40
55
35
30
35
45
45
50
55
45
35
35
Straight
4.27
AA
43
4
ML